ALDI USA Save the Holiday Spirit – Commercial Dud
Advertising, Featured Dec 07, 2025
ALDI USA’s 2025 holiday spot opens with Santa losing his footing and tumbling off a rooftop, landing on an ALDI van. The idea is that the truck saves Santa, and with him “the holiday spirit.” On paper that’s a tidy metaphor. On screen it feels overly simplistic and lacks cleverness.
What the spot gets wrong
The closing scene, where Santa strikes a surfer pose, comes across as dated and out of place. It’s the kind of button you add when the story hasn’t earned a real ending. The rescue itself is a sight gag, not an idea, and a sight gag doesn’t tell me anything about why I should shop at ALDI.
There’s even a legal super telling viewers that Santa is real, but an actor, and not to try this at home. When your Christmas commercial needs a stunt disclaimer, the stunt has become the message.
The one moment that works
The only truly charming moment is when a little girl wakes up and catches a glimpse of Santa through her window. It’s brief, but it’s heartfelt, and it’s the one beat that feels like Christmas instead of a slapstick reel. If I were building this spot again, I’d start there.
The strategy behind it
The campaign comes from Leo in Chicago, under ALDI USA’s “It’s an ALDI Thing” platform, and it was directed by Brian Billow. A second spot, “Accidental Party,” turns a Christmas freeze-frame into a showcase of ALDI’s seasonal products.
According to the agency, the goal was to move away from the price-led advertising of the year before and toward a more narrative, emotional “saving Christmas” story. That’s the right instinct. Discount grocers can’t win on price messaging alone during the holidays, when everyone is shouting about deals. Emotion is where brand preference gets built.
The problem is the execution. A narrative approach needs a narrative. Santa falling off a roof isn’t a story about ALDI helping families celebrate on a budget. It’s an accident that happens to involve a delivery van.
Compare that with ALDI UK
ALDI’s UK business has spent a decade building Kevin the Carrot into a beloved holiday character, with a new chapter every Christmas. Viewers look forward to it. That’s what a holiday campaign looks like when it’s built on an idea that can grow, instead of a single gag that’s over in 30 seconds.
My scorecard
- Concept: 3/10. A rescue gag stands in for an idea.
- Brand recall: 6/10. The van is front and center, so you’ll remember who it was.
- Craft: 6/10. It’s competently shot, but the surfer ending undercuts it.
- Would it sell? 4/10. Nothing here gives me a reason to change where I shop.
The verdict
The commercial feels rushed and conceptually uninspired. If I were the creative director, I’d have sent the storyboard and writing teams back to refine their ideas before moving forward. Start with the little girl at the window and build a real story about ALDI making the holidays possible. That’s the commercial this should have been.
Also see related advertising post Liberty Mutual Wet Teddy Bears